1 Padanaram Rd, Danbury, CT

Opened: around 2003

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ShopRite opened August 3, 2016

Read more here

160 W Putnam Ave, Greenwich, CT

Opened: unknown

Closed: October 17, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 21, 2015 

Read more here

1261 E Putnam Ave, Riverside, CT

Opened: unknown

Closed: October 17, 2016

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 21, 2025

1201 High Ridge Rd, Stamford, CT

Opened: 1960s

Closed: October 19, 2016

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 23, 2025

Read more here

45 De Mercurio Dr, Allendale, NJ

Opened: 1970s

Closed: October 12, 2016

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 16, 2015

Read more here

1002 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands, NJ

(also referred to as Navesink)

Opened: 1970s

Closed: by November 25, 2016

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• The space was subdivided between Dollar Tree (opened 2018) and The Goodwill Store (opened 2019).

Read more here

407 King George Rd, Basking Ridge, NJ

Opened: June 29, 2002

Closed: September 2015

❌Demolished

525 US-46 E, Belvidere, NJ

Opened: 1990s

Closed: September 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Family Dollar/Dollar Tree opened around 2022 

Read more here

152 NJ-94, Blairstown, NJ

Opened: 1990s

Closed: October 26, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 30, 2015. 

Read more here

19 Belleville Ave, Bloomfield, NJ

Opened: 1982

Closed: by November 25, 2016

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• SuperFresh Food World opened May 6, 2016. 

• The store was sold and rebranded to SuperFresh in late 2020.

Read more here

550 Myrtle Ave, Boonton, NJ

Opened: 1999

Closed: November 20, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened September 16, 2016

Read more here

64 Brick Plaza, Brick, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: by November 25, 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• The space was subdivided between Michaels, opened June 2017, and HomeGoods, opened June 2018

431 CR-513, Califon, NJ

Opened: 1970s

Closed: September 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Aqui Market opened in 2018

Read more here

1060 Raritan Rd, Clark, NJ

Opened: around 2005

Closed: October 21, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 25, 2015

Read more here

325 NJ-35 S, Cliffwood, NJ

(also referred to as Aberdeen or Keyport)

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: September 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Sprouts Farmers Market opened June 7, 2024

Read more here

49 Old Route 22, Clinton, NJ

Opened: 1970s

Closed: November 2015

❌Demolished

Read more here

400 Demarest Ave, Closter, NJ

Opened: 1960s

Closed: October 31, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Stop & Shop opened November 6, 2015

123 Main St, Denville, NJ

Opened: 2003

Closed: October 21, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 25, 2015

Read more here

1185 Amboy Ave, Edison, NJ

Opened: 1983

Closed: September 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• SuperFresh opened late July 2016 and closed October 2017

• Lotte Plaza Market opened July 26, 2019

Read more here

425 Anderson Ave, Fairview, NJ

Opened: 1993

Closed: November 22, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Food Bazaar opened November 10, 2016

Read more here

105 South Ave, Fanwood, NJ

Opened: 1960s

Closed: November 19, 2015

❌Demolished

2160 Lemoine Ave, Fort Lee, NJ

Opened: early 2000s as A&P; ca. 2000 as The Food Emporium

Closed: October 10, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 14, 2015

Read more here

7 Naughright Rd, Hackettstown, NJ

Opened: 1999

Closed: November 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Shop Fresh Marketplace opened March 3, 2023 and closed September 6, 2023

• Nature's Food Markets opened May 3, 2024

Read more here

614 Clinton St, Hoboken, NJ

Opened: 1998

Closed: November 4, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 8, 2015

Read more here

2101 NJ-35, Holmdel, NJ

Opened: 1980s

Closed: September 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Hobby Lobby opened September 2017

Read more here

125 18th St, Jersey City, NJ

Opened: 1988 as Waldbaum's, around 1993 as A&P

Closed: November 1, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 4, 2015

Read more here

801 Kenilworth Blvd, Kenilworth, NJ

Opened: 1995

Closed: October 28, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 1, 2015

Read more here

507 Prospect Ave, Little Silver, NJ

Opened: 1950s

Closed: November 4, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 4, 2015

Read more here

125 Franklin Tpk, Mahwah, NJ

Opened: mid-1990s

Closed: October 15, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 18, 2015

Read more here

460 CR-520, Marlboro, NJ

Opened: early 1971

Closed: November 27, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• The Food Emporium opened May 11, 2018

Read more here

137 Lake St, Midland Park, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: October 11, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 14, 2015

Read more here

510 Valley Rd, Montclair, NJ

Opened: 1960s

Closed: October 7, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 11, 2015

Read more here

1260 Springfield Ave, New Providence, NJ

Opened: 2010

Closed: November 2, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 6, 2015

Read more here

510 Milltown Rd, North Brunswick, NJ

Opened: early 2000s

Closed: November 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• LIDL opened July 29, 2020

Read more here

5774 Berkshire Valley Rd, Oak Ridge, NJ

Opened: around 2005

Closed: October 28, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 1, 2015

Read more here

3500 US-9, Old Bridge, NJ

Opened: 1970s

Closed: November 4, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 8, 2015

Read more here

216 Old Tappan Rd, Old Tappan, NJ

Opened: 1998

Closed: November 25, 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Foodtown opened late November 2015 and closed in July 2019

Read more here

199 Kinderkamack Rd, Park Ridge, NJ

Opened: 1960s

Closed: October 12, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 16, 2015 and closed November 10, 2018

• LIDL opened October 2020

Read more here

47 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: September 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• LIDL opened September 1, 2021

148 Center Grove Rd, Randolph, NJ

Opened: early 2000s

Closed: March 2000

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Weis Markets opened July 19, 2018

Read more here

75 Mayhill St, Saddle Brook, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: October 14, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 18, 2015

Read more here

5 Ortley Plaza, Seaside Heights, NJ

(also referred to as Ortley Beach)

Opened: 1980s

Closed: October 31, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 4, 2015

Read more here

Image courtesy of Lucas F.

907 Oak Tree Rd, South Plainfield, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: October 28, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 1, 2015 and closed November 2017

• ALDI opened December 9, 2020

Read more here

455 NJ-23 N, Sussex, NJ

Opened: 1960s

Closed: October 26, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 30, 2015

Read more here

990 Shrewsbury Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: November 7, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 11, 2015 and closed February 22, 2019

• Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace opened April 21, 2023

Read more here

530 CR-515, Vernon, NJ

Opened: mid-1990s

Closed: October 26, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 30, 2015

Read more here

2007 NJ-35, Wall, NJ

Opened: 1980s

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened on November 6, 2015

177 Washington Valley Rd, Warren, NJ

Opened: around 1980

Closed: November 2, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 6, 2015

Read more here

560 Valley Rd, Wayne, NJ

Opened: 1980s

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Wayne Natural Food Market was planned but never opened

• Whole Foods Market opened September 17, 2020

Read more here

315 Pascack Rd, Washington, NJ

Opened: 1998

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Nicholas Markets Foodtown opened in late November 2015

• The store was converted to Nicholas Markets The Fresh Grocer in early 2020

Read more here

459 NJ-31 S, Washington, NJ

(also referred to as Hampton)

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: November 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• LD Distribution opened around 2022

Read more here

1938 Union Valley Rd, West Milford, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: November 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Highland's Market by Shopwell opened October 16, 2020 and closed early 2022

• Cosmo's Fresh Market opened November 2022 and closed September 29, 2024

Read more here

Photo courtesy of Lucas F.

19-21 Avenue at Port Imperial, West New York, NJ

Opened: 1998

Closed: October 5, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 9, 2015

Read more here

520 Chestnut Ridge Rd, Woodcliff Lake, NJ

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: October 12, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 16, 2015 and closed October 2, 2019

• Whole Foods Market opened July 7, 2022

Read more here

1730 US-46 W, Woodland Park, NJ

Opened: around 2000

Closed: November 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• The space was subdivided

• AndThat! opened on August 25, 2017 and closed August 2023

• World Market opened September 14, 2017

422 Old Post Rd, Bedford, NY

Opened: around 2005 as A&P, previously as Shopwell/The Food Emporium

Closed: November 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Key Food opened late 2015 and closed early 2020

• DeCicco & Sons opened March 25, 2022

1511 NY-22, Brewster, NY

Opened: around 2000

Closed: October 24, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 28, 2015

1886 Pleasantville Rd, Briarcliff Manor, NY

Opened: unknown

Closed: October 19, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 23, 2015

Read more here

5661 Riverdale Ave, Bronx, NY

Opened: around 2010 as A&P; previously as The Food Emporium/Shopwell

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Key Food opened late 2015, then briefly closed in the summer of 2020 during an ownership change

Read more here

12-14 Cedar St, Bronxville, NY

Opened: 1990s

Closed: October 14, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 18, 2015

Read more here

2005 Albany Post Rd, Croton-on-Hudson, NY

Opened: around 1970

Closed: November 9, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Foodtown opened November 10, 2015

Read more here

777 White Plains Rd, Eastchester, NY

(also referred to as Scarsdale)

Opened: unknown

Closed: October 12, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 16, 2015 and closed November 4, 2019

• DeCicco & Sons opened October 9, 2020

100 NY-22, Goldens Bridge, NY

Opened: 1960s

Closed: October 21, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 25, 2015

Read more here

103 Knollwood Rd, Greenburgh, NY

(also referred to as White Plains)

Opened: unknown

Closed: October 7, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 11, 2015

355 Halstead Ave, Harrison, NY

Opened: around 2010

Closed: November 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• The Harrison Market opened late 2015 and closed May 15, 2024

Read more here

87 Main St, Hastings-on-Hudson, NY

Opened: early 1960s

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Foodtown opened August 4, 2016

Read more here

829 NY-82, Hopewell Junction, NY

Opened: 2005

Closed: October 24, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 18, 2015

1643 NY-82, LaGrangeville, NY

Opened: late 1990s

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ShopRite opened April 14, 2016

Read more here

3 Village Center, Mahopac, NY

Opened: 1990s

Closed: October 24, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 28, 2015

805 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY

Opened: around 1980

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• North Shore Farms opened June 26, 2020

230 Saw Mill River Rd, Millwood, NY

Opened: 1960s

Closed: September 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• DeCicco & Sons opened December 30, 2016

3105 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY

Opened: around 2000

Closed: October 24, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 28, 2015

195 N Bedford Rd, Mount Kisco, NY

Opened: 2005

Closed: November 12, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Stop & Shop opened November 19, 2015

23 Quaker Ridge Rd, New Rochelle, NY

Opened: around 2010; previously as Shopwell/The Food Emporium

Closed: October 12, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 16, 2015

3101 NY-22, Patterson, NY

Opened: around 2000

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened August 26, 2016

20 Welcher Ave, Peekskill, NY

Opened: 1959

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Key Food opened April 7, 2016 and closed April 25, 2017

• Peekskill Green Grocers opened May 2017 and closed in late 2019

• Apple Farm opened November 2020

13 North Ave, Pleasant Valley, NY

Opened: around 1990

Closed: October 26, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 30, 2015

261 S Ridge St, Rye Brook, NY

Opened: around 2010 as A&P; previously as Shopwell/The Food Emporium

Closed: October 17, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 21, 2015

668 Central Park Ave, Scarsdale, NY

Opened: around 1960

Closed: by November 2015

❌Not still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• 24 Hour Fitness opened December 30, 2018

1366 E Main St, Shrub Oak, NY

Opened: 1960s

Closed: October 28, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened November 1, 2015

Read more here

610 Columbus Ave, Thornwood, NY

Opened: unknown

Closed: October 19, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 23, 2015

14 Lake Ridge Plaza, Valley Cottage, NY

Opened: around 1980

Closed: by November 25, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• Foodtown opened August 4, 2016

Read more here

660 McLean Ave, Yonkers, NY

Opened: around 1990

Closed: October 18, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 21, 015

Read more here

100 Triangle Center, Yorktown, NY

Opened: unknown

Closed: October 22, 2015

✅Still a supermarket

Later Tenants:

• ACME Markets opened October 25, 2015